1 / 20
May 2016

Hello! I am the creator of WintreKitty Reviews, and one of the first reviewers to start here on Tapastic. Review blogs, videos, and magazines have been getting fairly popular here now, which is SUPER exciting!

I know that lots of you comic creators are constantly looking for your comic to get a solid review from someone, but it can be difficult to locate the reviewers since we are few and far between, and many of us close our wait lists because of the mass amount of requests.

So, I'm calling all reviewers to unite! Please leave a link to your review sites, YouTube, or other locations so that comic creators can find and contact you! If you know anyone else who is still actively taking reviews, link them here too!

I'll link everyone's sites on this post as well for quick and easy access to the reviewers:

Critics who may or may not be taking requests but are worth checking out:

Cheers,
WintreKitty

  • created

    May '16
  • last reply

    Jun '22
  • 19

    replies

  • 2.6k

    views

  • 9

    users

  • 24

    likes

  • 11

    links

@konniemay does reviews on their youtube channel5, although they're having internet issues, so they haven't been active for a bit. I know of other general webcomic review sites, but not any who are active on Tapastic, unfortuately. ):

Thanks, I'll add them to the active reviewers list. @konniemay, if you aren't active anymore, let me know smile
@Panda007 I also added you to the list, so let me know as well if you aren't actively taking reviews anymore.

I'm always taking reviews, it might just take a while.

Iust remembered this thread5, I know not all of the people on there have Tapastic accounts or have been that active, but it might help a little bit with your list.
If I heard right, I think konniemay might be going through problems with their internet, so they might not be posting much for a while.

12 days later
6 months later

Apparently I can't continually edit the main post, there seems to be a time limit or something on it. But there is another reviewer who is active and taking requests. You can ask for a review by Infected Blood Comics, which you can find here6.

Thanks much! I had the same problem with an old thread I opened a while ago. After some time, you can't edit the original post anymore. It would be nice to open a new thread, but of course is up to you. Cheers 😀

I might start a new one. Once I have some time to go through all of these review pages again and see who is still active, or is active again, then I will see if a new thread is wise or not. Also depends on peoples' interest in seeing a list of reviewers. I'm not sure how many people are actually seeing this post haha

Now that we pushed the thread up to the top, I'm sure it will be visible again and people will read it 😀

5 years later

Interesting. Haven;t considered reviewers. Im pretty clueless on that topic.
Since your on this thread, could you share some like.. rules or guidelines for creators? Like...

-Do reviewers pick what they want to review? or should creators be sending them stuff?
-Do reviewers stick to a specific genre? should creators figure that out before submitting a comic?
-Do reviewers discuss what they're gonna say with creators at all? or do they just go for it, and the creator has to deal.
-If you've submitted your comic, and never heard back, should you submit again? or is that super annoying.

Can't think of anymore right now. just never really looked in to comic reviews much. thanks for sharing.

hm. actually most of those links are dead. what seemed like a helpful thread, might not really be so great. ah well. it is something to think about.

9 days later

closed Jun 20, '22