25 / 31
Feb 2021

I actually find it easier to look at. I think its in the way everything's blended together.

Edit to add - it feels softer honestly

Well this is just rough doodles, i usually sketch with very thin lines because i am used to manual watercolor :sweat_smile: but i can make it tidier and thicker. But you have good point, i mean every comic for me would be better in watercolor because i’m very biased. But the cel shading is faster, i think. Objectively idk which is better with fantasy genre though. Thanks a lot <3

Ahh I see i see. In that case I think it's hard to draw an accurate comparison/judgement if more factors than just the coloring would be different between the two :sweat_smile: would have to see 2 "final" versions next to each other.

That said! I'm also part of the "watercolor is super pretty" squad and wouldn't mind seeing more comics like that :smirk:

Ahaha that’s right i should post the final one instead lmao. Yeah, also l have never made comics before so i don’t know in the long run which one will prevail(both in terms of motivation and effectiveness) :sweat_smile:
Yeeeesss watercolor rules /o/

I like the one on the left for the simple reason that the character's face is what you see. The one on the right presents a big blob of color (a nice blob but a big one) that, to me, detracts from the character's face.

I didn't even notice the difference in the character's hair and facial shading because of the larger area of color.

All that said, it depends on what you want people to notice.

But my forte is novel writing, not comic work so you would know best.

I prefer the watercolour version. I think it handles light better than the cel shaded one.

Yeah, the cel shaded one is more sloppy, i guess, since i very rarely color with cel shading one too. I don’t even know what i want vs what works. I think i need to sleep on this first lmao. Thanks a lot though <3

Personally I prefer the stronger color choices of the one on the right cause it feels a lot more confident, but the one on the left has some nice texture to it. You might be able to combine these to make something better than either one individually.

How to combine both....looks like i need more experiment XD thanks for the suggestion /o/

As someone already said I think it depends on the mood of the comic. I love the left one as an illustration, but would probably prefer the right one in a comic (I like a bolder style personally). Have you tried making a whole page to compare the styles?

I prefer the one on the right, but I'd probably go with the one that takes less time to draw.

I do prefer the watercolour one, but as others have said I think it would depend on what kind of setting you're trying to create for your story. Watercolour would be lovely for a romantic or nostalgic comic, no so much a high adrenaline spy thriller, y'know?

I like the watercolor one! It reminds me of those old botanical watercolor studies I love-

Tough to say, depends on how you're using them. The left looks like it's outside in the bright daylight, whereas the right looks more like it's in a brightly lit hospital or clinical setting.

I like the one on the right because it reads a little clearer. The one on the left is really nice too, but it has a little too much texture maybe. You're style is really nice btw.

Since my comic is in fantasy genre, and it’ll have a lil bit of action scenes, i decided to go with the second one. Thank you guys for the inputs, i really appreciate it /o/

I prefer the water color one, but also it's super important to choose a style that you can do quickly. Every extra step you add will add on time and be torture later.