3 / 15
Nov 2018

This has been in the back of my mind for a while. I'm currently making a comic that I've been developing for a very long time and I grew very attached to it. But in the process of making the comic, I never felt satisfied with how it was turning out and I always feel frustrated. So right now I'm conflicted whether I should do a different, smaller projects first to increase my skill and come back to it later or should i just keep going with it?

  • created

    Nov '18
  • last reply

    Nov '18
  • 14

    replies

  • 1.3k

    views

  • 15

    users

  • 38

    likes

I would advise you to do the smaller project first. Take a little break, and then continue with it after you develop them more. It will be less of a burden for you.

Personally I'm a huge advocate in general of starting out with smaller projects before working your way up to the really big, ambitious dream project. That's what I'm doing, anyway, since I know for a fact that if I tried to do certain things at my current level of skill they wouldn't turn out as well as I want them to. There's no harm in putting it on the shelf for a while; it'll still be there when you're ready for it :slight_smile:

I also recommend doing little projects, when i feel that way i leave it for a while and come back later because if i dont, it affects the work i do and the way it looks at the end(in a bad way).

the smaller projects sound like the best alternative. I started working on my main comic and I really wanted the art to show some spark. I started with manga black and white and after 150 pages I realized it was not working for me U_U I had to redraw 3 chapters. Literally re-do all my work. I think that if you are not satisfied now, you probably will be even more unhappy later that you gain more experience. Because the more we learn the more the past mistakes become evident.

You feel frustrated and un-satisfied because you know there are problems in your project, but you don't know how to fix those.

Keep pratice on some small projects, and take everything you do slowly and steady.
You need to learn not only to improve your skills, but also your ability to solve problems.

And the most important is, you have to enjoy what you do.
If you're not enjoying it, you're doing it wrong. :grinning:

everyone is recommending small projects, but you'll never get anywhere unless you're happy with the project you're doing. follow your heart. for me, that meant the big project, even if there was a major (ongoing) learning curve. there's always a learning curve if you're not stagnating.

As a general rule I think it's wiser to do some smaller projects. I think just the act of making something that can be finished in a reasonable amount of time is a good idea. That said, I've never personally had the stomach for small projects, so when I decided I wanted to start actually making a web comic I just picked the story I felt like working on and went for it.

If you can do a small project, do it. But you do need to also weigh your inspiration. Think about what feels right to you. You'll be continuously improving, no matter what projects you pick, as long as you work hard.

thats the artist life. youre constantly improving and striving to improve, and the downside is that youll rarely / never be satisfied

that said...

this is a good idea! go for this!

working on smth smaller that youre less invested in is a really great way to develop skills

I agree with the smaller project idea. Maybe it would also be useful to go back to the basics, and accompany that smaller project with some studies and art theory relevant to the aspect you feel are currently your weak points

Biiiiiig agree with SleepingPoppy. Small projects make a lot of sense on paper, and you do have to be okay with the fact that you're going to do a lot of growing in your first comic project, no matter what it is. If you just can't get going on your Big Project and doing something smaller will get you going and help be less perfectionist, sweet! Go for it! But that doesn't work for everyone, so if you try this strategy and find out it's not working for you, that's okay too!!

Also wanna note, bouncing between a few different ideas can help keep your inspiration going, for some folks. Putting something on the backburner when it gets frustrating and working on something else for a bit to clear your brain or get it on a different track, so you can come back to the first project with new eyes after a bit, isn't giving up on a project; it's a valid part of the process. LOTS of creators need breaks to work on other things -- that's how you grow!!

Your OP describes exactly the situation that I found myself in at the beginning of this year, ~January. I had just started the "final reboot" on this huge comic I've been slowly developing since like... 2007-ish? Middle School all the way up through post-college. Anyways the problem was that I started drawing it in Decemeber and it was the end of January and I was only 8 pages in, and even as a action fantasy type series, I probably wasn't going to get to the first action sequence until like... now-ish.

Basically I realized both that my story was too large and poorly cobbled together (the resutls of 10 years worth of writing and reboots, but without the story even being done and full of ideas that middle school me thought were good) and just that pursuing a project like that as a first project would have been an awful idea. No need chaining myself down to somehting like that when I'm still learning/practicing, ya know?

So I decided to promptly halt that project and started writing my current one shot shortly thereafter in February. This story is a neat tidy 50-60 pages that i know I can finish :> and the good part wont/didn't take forever to get to. And my drawing speed (in terms of pages per week) has already improved significantly. And I'm just learning "how to comic" better. Wins all around.

I don't know yet whether I'll return to that previous series or not, but I'm not too concerned about it for the time being. Since that story's something of a passion project to me, I'd like to draw it some day, but hopefully with a bunch more comic making (and editing!) skills in my pocket xD In the mean time I'm pursuing some smaller projects! I'm planning on following my current one-shot with 1 or 2 shorter stories set in the same world upon completion, and I'm in the process of wirting a short-ish length series I'd like to tackle after those :> That'll be my first "lots of chapters" project, but hopefully not toooooo many, and I'm planning to have the whole thing written out before I start so I know exactly what I'm getting into!

I agree with everybody above. :slight_smile:

If you're feeling frustrated, it might be a good idea to put it aside and work on something else for a while. It would be too bad to grow to dislike your big project because you can't get it to look like what you imagined. :confused:

A couple smaller projects could be nice! Smaller stories don't require a lot of commitment, so they're perfect to improve your art skills, your storytelling, etc...
That's what I'm currently aiming to do, for a year at least! I have a lot of smaller stories in mind, and I intend to draw them one after the other, every time focusing on a new aspect to improve. During my current story I'm focusing on my backgrounds and my shading.

The most important thing is for you to have fun and enjoy the process of making your comics! :slight_smile: When it becomes more negative than positive, then maybe it is time to do something else for a while...

Don't get discouraged. :heart: You're doing awesome!

The "start small" idea has already been covered so i want to say something else..

Allow yourself to make a abhorrent trash and allow yourself to try again. Test the waters, keep treading, but if you need a raft get on it.

Webcomics are ultimately for their creator and thus you CAN make mistakes and learn from them. You will always have the option to go back and try again.

Reboot hell is a thing sure but if you are so unhappy that you only feel demotivation..then shake things up.

If you want to make a giant fantasy epic then so be it. Just dont shoot yourself down as soon as you start walking.

I wouldn't completely scrap this bigger comic, I would put on hold to make short stories. I have made two myself and its a completely different experience. It will definitely put you writing skills to the test and you can finish it in a reasonable amount of time.