OH for my intentionally unattractive characters, I'd have to go back to 2011 with a graphic novel about a soccer/football team from a fictional Central Asian country.
Beni is the goalkeeper. I made him a bit dorky-looking, with acne, ears that stick out, and a cowlick. But he really is the heart of the team.

The other one is Tokki, one of the forwards. I intentionally made him a contrast to the other regular forward who is attractive and a bit full of himself. But they both get along well enough~

I still think they're both cute in their own way!