3 / 10
Jan 2020

Hi fellow creators,

My main 2020 goal (probably as many people here) is to get featured on webtoon,
Thus I've started working twice as hard on my webcomic, I'm spending 6 days/7 working on it so that I can provide at least 40 panels each Week (not as hard as I thought once you find a Schedule that suits you!), I also started Editing some of my first episodes because after getting several reviews I realized that they were of a lower quality than my most recent ones.

So I'm trying to gather as many informations as possible on the dos and Don't regarding webtoon comics, i found a lot of posts talking about censored nudity and explicit content in general, here's what I was wondering :

  • Are curse words an issue?
  • Which amount of nudity is allowed and ni which context? (Like one of my episode has the main protagonist shirtless in the shower, is that an issue or not?
  • I noticed featured webtoons either change famous brands name or put '**' (when their characters use facebook for example) is that an obligation? Does it Apply to everything? (brands, companies, songs, artists, movies etc?)
  • My webtoon is fantasy/ romance : is blood/violence allowed if I put a warning at the beginning of the concerned épisodes? Same for romance, my characters are 17yrs old and I'd like to adress topics such as couple intimacy, first love etc in a way that'd be as realistic as possible, thus is talking about sexual relationships an issue as well?

Thanks for taking the time to read this post!
Charlie

  • created

    Jan '20
  • last reply

    Jan '20
  • 9

    replies

  • 7.3k

    views

  • 8

    users

  • 7

    likes

  • 2

    links

Based on my own experience posting https://tapas.io/series/BDSM-Boys48 on webtoon:
-cursing - not an issue
-nudity I had some pages removed and had to change some panels
tapas:


webtoon:

(not sure if nipples were really the issue, I had a little bit of back and forth with webtoon stuff before I got the pages back up)
tapas:

webtoon:

tapas:

webtoon:

-have no idea about brands, but I think it's better in general to avoid those (personally I just don't like real life brands being mentioned in fiction ;p)
-as for anything adult oriented, my suggestion is to just keep it teen friendly

I am not a featured creater. But I have been staff picked before and passed the ad revenue review, so I assume I meet their criteria for being safe.

There is a bit of swearing in my comic ("fuck" on the first page, even) and mostly full female nudity, but with no nipples or genitalia showing. And nothing in a sexual context, which might explain why I've never had a problem with posting nudity even though the person above me has.

I've never talked about sex, but there's a featured comic, "Boo! It's Sex" that is explicitly about sex education. So it seems candid discussion about sex is fine.

im really curious about gore and violence with webtoons and what they will allow

I think they aren’t soo tight with gore and violence like they are with sexual stuff.
I think blood splattering and such is ok. As soon as you see a severe wound (or severed limbs) they tend to censor the area where the wound is with pixels...
so, yeah, just censor the hardcore stuff and you should be fine :slight_smile:

I think it’s as much with staying in the App Store as anything.
They have plenty of horror, so you should be okay if you stay away from hard gore.

I don't work with webtoons or really post on there, but I do read a lot of webtoons, so I kinda know what is and isn't allowed.
Curse words are normally fine, but I think they prefer it if you censor the word a bit. Nudity is normally fine as well as long as it isn't too sexual. Shirtless scenes are totally fine, especially if the character is male (I'm not sure how they feel about female nipples though, so be careful with that). Blood and violence is also allowed, but comics that often have stuff like that are marked as mature and the reader has to confirm that they are of a certain age before reading (for example Uriah68). Discussing sexual topics should also be fine.
For the brand censoring, thats because of copyrights and trademarks. Comics normally censor out or change a brand/company/song/artist/movie/etc name because they don't have the legal rights to use it in a webtoon that they are being paid to make. Most people don't know which brand names and stuff you are and aren't allowed to use in commercial material, so they normally just censor/change any names they think there might be an issue with.

If you were to get featured on webtoon, you would get an editor who would know all the rules that your comic has to follow. So you don't need to stress too much about it. As long as your comic isn't 18+ (unnecessary sexual content, lots of unnecessary violence etc), it should be fine.

Thank you! This helps a lot, especially about the brand censoring, since canvas doesn't allow music in episodes, I try to give a dynamic to some of mine by adding scenes where my characters are listening to certain type of songs that help set the mood of a scene, and I didn't how to do about mentionning the artist or not, what I did so far is that I usually spell the song's titles right but either cut the artist name of change it a little bit and then mention it properly in the comments or the notes section for people to find it easily afterwards!

You know I've been curious about this, too. My first chapter literally has a head being severed (oops oof spoilers or whatever:p) and I've been trying to figure out how in the hell to censor it for Webtoon use.

Check out ‘Sweet home’. In the current chapter they have a scene that’s similar to your problem (although there they censored everything. But it still might be a good example :slight_smile:
Overall I would recommend ‘Sweet home’ and ‘Bastard’ as a guideline how far you can go with uncensored and censored gore. Booth comics have their fair share of blood.

@topic:
So cuss words are mostly ok when censored.
I’m curious, does anyone knows how they are with sexual slangs? I’m especially curious about the word ‘Pussy’. Do you think that’s ok, censored or not. Or should I stay away from it all together
(In the context I need it it would be a kinda a word play so.....yes, it would refer to a woman’s private part :scream:)